[c-nsp] GRE tunnel to do span vlan across two datacenters?

[Derick Winkworth]

If you are not already running MPLS, then I would rule VPLS out... though there are some benefits to biting the bullet and learning MPLS and virtualizing your network with it.
L2TPv3 is a better option than GRE, in my opinion.  Also having dark fiber means large MTUs yes?  I think that would be preferable... 


--- On Wed, 7/6/11, Jason Gurtz <jasongurtz at npumail.com> wrote:

From: Jason Gurtz <jasongurtz at npumail.com>
Subject: [c-nsp] GRE tunnel to do span vlan across two datacenters?
To: cisco-nsp at puck.nether.net
Date: Wednesday, July 6, 2011, 11:08 AM

A firm has proposed creating a GRE tunnel between two datacenters (using a
3750X stack at each) to create the spanned vlans needed for VMWare
failover application.

Clearly there is tunnel overhead but I sense there are other failure modes
here that aren't so clear to me--I am familiar in concept with GRE tunnels
but don't have a heck of a lot of opex. Can anyone share more insight on
the merit (or lack of) with this proposed design? I am aware (via this
list, thanks!) of several shortcomings surrounding 3750 based stacks, but
cisco alternatives seem pricier still or too big. There is dark fiber
available, what about VPLS w/ LDP or L2TP solution?

Current network is L3 at the access layer w/ OSPF (4507-sup6 access, 4900M
cores):

     A1
     /\
   /    \
 C1------C2
   \    /
     \/
     A2

Maybe it is better to just overlay stp back on to the network w/root and
alt-root at C1/C2 (V1 and V2 are the proposed 3750X stacks)? Scary to me,
but an an argument can be made for less complexity -vs.- tunnling/vpn
based approach.

     A1     .V1
     /\ . ' /
   /. ' \ /
 C1------C2
   \` . / \
     \/ ' . \
     A2     'V2

OTOH, by the time this actually gets done maybe TRILL will be out ;)
Hopefully this enterprisy topic is not too OT!

~JasonG



_______________________________________________
cisco-nsp mailing list  cisco-nsp at puck.nether.net
https://puck.nether.net/mailman/listinfo/cisco-nsp
archive at http://puck.nether.net/pipermail/cisco-nsp/