[c-nsp] ISR G2 Licenses - Permanent vs Right To Use

[Steve McCrory]

Hi Reuben,

Thanks for the information.

So essentially, as long as we have evidence that we purchased the
license (distributor should be able to provide this) then we are covered
for using an RTU license?

Steven

-----Original Message-----
From: Reuben Farrelly [mailto:reuben-cisco-nsp at reub.net] 
Sent: 28 November 2012 12:23
To: Steve McCrory
Cc: cisco-nsp NSP
Subject: Re: [c-nsp] ISR G2 Licenses - Permanent vs Right To Use

On 28/11/2012 10:52 PM, Steve McCrory wrote:
> Hi Group,
>
> We've had a complaint from a customer that their security license on a
> 1941K9 is showing as Right To Use when they are expecting it to show
> Permanent:
>
> Index 2 Feature: securityk9
>
>           Period left: Life time
>           License Type: RightToUse
>           License State: Active, In Use
>           License Count: Non-Counted
>           License Priority: Low
>
> We've had this checked with our distributor who shipped us the router
> pre-installed with the required license and they are happy that Right
To
> Use is correct. They even raised it with Cisco and they came back
> quoting the Wassenaar Arrangement.
>
> Can someone clear up the difference between the two terms as the Cisco
> literature on the subject is confusing and our customer is like a dog
> with a bone over this.

RightToUse (RTU) license are licenses that essentially are just honor 
based, ie you can freely use the features providing you have purchased 
the license, and there is no enforcement of the featureset on or off. 
This is basically how Cisco has historically licensed IOS for many
years.

Permanent licenses are ones where a license key has been imported into 
the router IOS and are based on a cryptographic license key file.  These

are node-locked licenses and tied to the serial number of the chassis. 
With a bit of messing around these can be transferred if you do an RMA.

If you've paid for and are entitled to a given featureset then yes, you 
should be getting what is called a Product Activation Key (PAK), which 
in turn you enter in to www.cisco.com/go/license, which then spits out a

tiny license key file that you install on the router.  This then shows 
up as a 'permanent' license in the IOS.  Either that, or the license is 
pre-installed at the factory in which case it will show as a permanent 
license out of the box.  This is how it normally works, I've had dozens 
of routers shipped to us from our distributor that are done this way.

Cisco went down the path of enforcing licensing (ie permanent licenses, 
no RTU) on some newer IOS platforms but did a fast backpedal in a 
15.0/15.1 maintenance rebuild of IOS.  Presumably a few people seriously

objected to it and the messing around involved in processing licenses, 
and Cisco realised it probably was causing more pain and lost sales than

it was worth.  So pretty much across the board in so far as branch 
routers now we're back to where we started, ie honor based RTU licenses 
where the real proof of entitlement is a purchase order proving you've 
bought the license :-)

Reuben



 
Steve McCrory
Senior Network Engineer
  
GCI Com
Cedar Court Office Park
Denby Dale Road
Calder Grove
Wakefield
WF4 3QZ
 
Office:   0844 443 3537
Fax:      0844 443 3540
http://www.gcicom.net/