[Irtf-rr] Presentations from San Diego

Yakov Rekhter yakov at juniper.net
Tue Aug 10 10:40:16 EDT 2004


Avri,

Quoting from draft-irtf-routing-history-01.txt (section 2.1):

   RFC1126 outlined a set of requirements that were to guide the
   development of BGP. 

The above statement is blatantly false. The development of BGP
was NOT guided by rfc1126, and I know this for a fact, as I am one
of the co-authors of the BGP spec (starting from rfc1105).

With this in mind I would suggest to replace the above sentence with
the following:

   The development of BGP happened completely independently of 
   RFC1126. In other words, from the point of view of the development
   of BGP, RFC1126 is totally irrelevant.

Yakov.


More information about the irtf-rr mailing list